Today we will consider the fundamentals of Real Estate financing approval. The first thing that we need to review is what a bank looks for in a prospective borrower. There is a simple way to remember the 5 key factors a bank looks at when considering a loan. The acronym is MICCE.
M is for Money. The bank wants to know if the borrower has sufficient funds to close. The bank looks at your available cash reserves or savings to ensure that you have enough for a down payment, if necessary, and if you have enough money on hand to cover your closing costs. The bank may also want you to have sufficient funds in savings as a reserve for two or three months of expenses.
I is for Income. The bank wants to know the nature of your income and the length of time you have had such a level of income. They will also want to know if there is the likelihood for the income to change in the future.
The first C in the acronym is for Credit. The bank wants to know the credit-worthiness of the borrower. The bank will request that you permit them to conduct a credit search on you. Typically, the bank will pull a report from the three major rating agencies. All three agencies currently use the FICO rating system which gives a three digit score for the borrower. Generally, the lowest is around 400 and the highest is 800. Anything above 650 is considered very good. 700 and higher is excellent. Each of the agencies can have very different information as some creditors may or may not report to a particular agency. The higher your credit score the lower the risk for the bank.
Your credit score is incredibly important in the borrowing process and you should do everything within your power to ensure that you have an accurate credit report. Recent legislation has made it mandatory that each of the three agencies provide a consumer, upon request, a copy of their written credit report. This free copy will not contain your FICO score but it will have everything else on it. You are entitled to this report once each year from each agency. This report can be obtained online.
Review your report and contact the reporting agency should you find any incorrect information.
The second C in the acronym is for Collateral. The bank wants to know what assets you have as collateral for this loan. The primary asset will be the property, itself, for which you are borrowing. The bank wants to ensure that there is sufficient value in the property. An appraisal will tell the bank what similar homes have sold for in a relatively recent period of time. Although an appraisal is not an exact evaluation of the property, it is as close as you can get to one. As we have discussed in a previous blog entry, a home is ONLY worth what someone is willing to pay for it.
The last letter in the acronym is E which stands for Employment. Now, like me, you initially may be somewhat confused. You believe that this was covered under the heading of Income. The fact is that INCOME has nothing to do with EMPLOYMENT. Many people have an income but are not employed.
There are two ways in this world to make money. The first is people at work and the second is money at work. If you are trading your time for someone else’s dollars then you are an example of people at work. If you do not trade your time for dollars and use your money to make money for you then you are using the money at work strategy. When the bank asks about your employment they want to know if you are employed and if so, for how long have you worked with your current employer. The bank will also want to know how long you have worked in your current field.
So there you have it, the 5 key factors a bank looks at when determining your ability to borrow certain sums of money. What is critically important to understand is that you are not REQUIRED to give all of the information to the bank when applying for a loan. Nowadays, banks have become rather creative in the financing process. A bank will consider you for a loan even if you refuse to provide information needed to satisfy one of the 5 keys. For example, you can still get funding for a loan to purchase real estate if you refuse to provide your income information to the bank. As a matter of fact, you can still get a loan even if you refuse to tell the bank about your assets and you refuse to give them information about your income.
What is important to remember is that it is a risk versus reward scenario for the bank. When you close their eyes to one or more of the 5 key factors you are increasing the risk the bank is taking in making this loan to you. For this increased risk the bank is going to look for a higher than usual reward. In this instance, the higher reward will be a higher interest rate on the loan. Conversely, the more information you provide the bank the lower the rate should be for your loan.
It doesn’t end there. The bank also employs a few standard ratios that you should be aware of when considering purchasing real estate. These ratios give an indication to the bank your ability to pay the monthly payments in addition to your current monthly obligations.
The first ratio is the Front End Debt Ratio or FEDR. This industry loves acronyms! The FEDR is calculated by dividing the Monthly Principal, Interest, Taxes and Insurance payment or the PITI, by the monthly gross income of the borrower(s). The bank likes to see a 28% ratio or LOWER on the FEDR. This is interesting because my husband’s father taught him, when he was young, to keep his housing payment to one quarter, 25%, of his monthly pay and to use the remaining three quarters on which to live and save.
The next ratio is very similar to the FEDR and it is known as the Back End Debt Ratio or BEDR. The BEDR is similar to the FEDR but it also incorporates your other monthly debt service or MDS. Your monthly debt service is the sum of all monthly payments required of you for revolving charges, installment loans or other obligations for which you make monthly payments. To calculate the BEDR you add together the PITI payment and your MDS and divide the total by your gross monthly income. The bank looks for a ratio of 36% or LOWER on the BEDR.
Of the two ratios, the most important to the bank is the BEDR. This is simply because it takes into consideration all of your financial obligations. It is important to note that if your ratios are not at the desired levels of 28% and 36%, respectively, you are still able to secure financing. Once again, it comes back to the risk versus reward scenario for the lender. If your ratios are higher, your interest rate will likely be higher. This is ironic because the higher the interest rate the higher the ratios will be. I believe they call this a “catch-22”. Where I am from, which is down south in Oklahoma, we look at it like a dog chasing his tail. Even if he catches it he sort of loses because he is actually biting himself in the behind.
Another important ratio the bank considers is the LTV – yes, another acronym, it stands for Loan to Value Ratio. The bank wants to know what percentage of the value of the home you are borrowing. That risk versus reward scenario is going to rear her hideous head again. The higher the LTV the lower the amount of equity you will have in the home and the higher the risk for the bank. The LTV is a simple calculation. You divide the amount of the loan by the appraised value of the property and express it in a percentage. For example, a home valued at $200,000 and a loan amount of $100,000 has a 50% LTV.
If your LTV exceeds 80% you will generally be required to pay Private Mortgage Insurance or PMI. This is not a pleasant situation for any borrower. PMI is generally expensive and not tax deductible. Further, it is somewhat difficult to remove from you loan. In many cases, you will need to wait a certain period of time and then provide an independent appraisal showing the value of your home and that you have 20% or more equity in the home. PMI protects the lender should you default on the loan. A common misconception about PMI is that it protects the borrower or it is a life insurance policy on the borrower. This is absolutely incorrect. PMI only protects the lender should you default on the loan.
Briefly, while on the topic of misconceptions, a pet peeve I have is that most people don’t understand that they do not GET a mortgage but rather GIVE a mortgage. You GET a loan and give, as collateral for the loan, a mortgage. I just had to get that off my chest, thank you for your indulgence.
So there you have it, the fundamentals of loan qualifications for real estate. To recap, the bank looks at 5 key factors in determining your eligibility to secure a loan (and GIVE a mortgage). The five keys are best remembered with an acronym MICCE; Money, Income, Credit, Collateral and Employment. The bank employs a few ratios in the process. The first is the FEDR or Front End Debt Ratio which is determined by dividing the PITI payment by the Monthly Gross Income. This ratio should be 28% or better (lower). The second ratio is the BEDR or Back End Debt Ratio which is calculated by adding the PITI and the MDS and dividing the total by the Monthly Gross Income. This ratio should be 36% or better (lower). The final ratio discussed in this blog entry is the LTV or Loan to Value ratio which is determined by dividing the loan amount by the value and expressing the result as a percentage. This ratio is ideal at 80% or lower.
While we are on the topic of loans I would like to add a few closing thoughts to consider. When you open up the local newspaper and turn to the mortgage rates, you need to understand that the rates listed in the paper are quotes and not offers. There is a substantial difference between a quote and an offer. A quote is a number given to you to peak your interest and to get you to consider a particular lender. A quote can be considered a “teaser”. An offer, however, is a rate provided by a lender which they know they could secure for you at a given time. Don’t allow yourself to be fooled by quotes and always ask for an offer. The offer should be in writing and should be accompanied by a GFE (another acronym!) or a Good Faith Estimate.
Before you go shopping for a new home, take a few minutes to understand or even master these concepts. Then contact a trusted loan officer. A loan officer is best found by referral. Ask your professional Realtor, your attorney or your accountant for a referral. Each of them should give you no less than three referrals. Your search for a loan officer will be short if the same name appears on all three lists. Alas, that is not likely, so take the time to measure twice and cut once! This is, most likely, the single largest purchase you will ever make. It is not often that you get the chance to do it again in situations such as this so you better make sure you get it right the first time. Call each of the referrals and ask to meet with them for a few minutes. Prepare a list of questions, comments and concerns, before the meeting and ask each of the prospective loan officers the same questions.
It won’t be long before you develop a comfort level with one of the referrals. Once you have selected a professional loan officer to work with ask him or her for a Pre-Qualification Letter or a Pre-Approval Letter. This will be very helpful in your search for a new home. It will give you a price range with which you should be comfortable.